Best 12V Cordless Reciprocating Saw Head-to-Head Review


DeWALT Maltschusser Compact Reciprocating Saw Review:

The DeWALT Maltschusser Compact Reciprocating Saw (MCS) is a compact cordless reciprocating saw which uses a motorized arm to cut through wood, plastic or other materials. The MCS is available in two models – the MCS-1 and the MCS-2. Both models are equipped with a 1/4″ blade, a 1/8″ blade and a 3/16″ blade. They both have an electric motor which operates at 2200 RPM and reaches speeds up to 20 feet per minute.

The MCS is powered by one 18650 Li-ion battery pack (included). It weighs approximately 5 pounds when fully loaded. The MCS comes with a rechargeable lithium ion battery pack which lasts for approximately 15 hours of continuous use. There is also an optional AC adapter cable.

The MCS has three settings: Low Power, Medium Power and High Power. When the user activates the switch on top of the unit, it switches from low power mode to medium power mode and then back to high power mode after 10 seconds. This allows the tool to be used for extended periods of time, as it automatically shuts off after 10 seconds.

The MCS has an electronic brake which prevents the saw from coasting after use. The electronic brake engages immediately after releasing the trigger. This prolongs the life of the saw.

The MCS is equipped with a durable metal gear case and an over-molded grip. The trigger on this saw has a soft start feature which prevents the blade from pulling the user’s hand when starting a cut.

The MCS comes with a 3-year limited warranty and a 30 day money back guarantee. It also comes with a belt hook, a blade wrench, the battery pack and a carrying case.

What Do I Like?

This reciprocating saw is powerful enough to cut through heavy duty materials. It has an over-molded grip and a metal gear case, so I know it’s going to last. The ability to set it up as either a lefty or a righty is a great feature and I’m really happy that it uses a standard blade that can be easily replaced. The battery charges quickly and the electronic brake is a nice touch.

What Can Be Improved?

It would be nice if there was a way to store the battery pack on the saw itself. The price is also pretty steep, but you get what you pay for and this tool is built to last. I might add that the customer service at DeWALT is excellent. I once had an issue with the battery and they quickly sent me a new one at no cost.

All in all, this is a great reciprocating saw. If you are looking for something that’s going to last, then you can’t go wrong with the DeWALT MCS.

Best 12V Cordless Reciprocating Saw Head-to-Head Comparison

When it comes to reciprocating saws, there are a few kinds on the market. The first type uses an electric motor to turn the blade. This is by far the most common type of reciprocating saw and it’s what I’ll refer to as a ‘normal’ saw. The other two types are called Sawsall’s and Chopsaws.

Best 12V Cordless Reciprocating Saw Head-to-Head Review at

Sawsalls have an engine powered by gasoline or diesel fuel. They are heavy duty tools used primarily in construction but can also be useful in emergency situations. The last type, a chop saw is typically used by carpenters and other woodworkers. It looks similar to a normal saw but it runs off of a specialized cartridge that contains interchangeable blades, guide rods and wrenches.


A regular reciprocating saw is the type you are probably most familiar with seeing on TV or in movies. These electric tools are extremely versatile and can be used for just about any kind of construction or remodeling project. They come in different voltages, which determine how powerful the tool is. The most common types are the 18V, the 26V and the 40V.

The saws I have chosen for this article are all 40V models because they offer the best of both worlds. The cutting power of a heavier duty tool without the excessively heavy weight.

18V Saws

These saws are lighter than their heavier duty counterparts and are a good option for hobbyists and homeowners. They are not powerful enough for construction work but you will probably have no trouble completing simple projects around the house.

26V Saws

These types of saws are heavier duty and more powerful than their 18V counterparts. They are a good choice for the serious DIY enthusiast who needs a tool that can tackle a variety of jobs. They are not quite as heavy duty as the 40V models so they won’t be ideal for professionals who do rough construction work on a daily basis. These are great for the average homeowner who wants one tool that can do it all.

40V Saws

These are the highest-end models and are designed for professionals. They have a powerful motor that turns the blade at a very high speed and can cut through most materials with ease. These are heavier than the other types of saws so they might not be the best option for hobbyists who need to carry their tools from place to place.

Reciprocating Saws vs Circular Saws

A few readers have asked me why they should choose a reciprocating saw over a circular saw. The main advantage of a reciprocating saw is that it has the power to cut through just about anything. It makes quick work of materials like brick, metal and concrete.

Best 12V Cordless Reciprocating Saw Head-to-Head Review at

It is also possible to get a reciprocating saw blade in a variety of different tooth structures. These blades can be used for more than just cutting material, they can also be hooked up to an air compressor to blow debris away or to cut through frozen material.

Reciprocating saws are not as versatile as a circular saw and are only really useful for cutting materials. If you only need to do that one task then a reciprocating saw will get the job done quicker and more efficiently.

Which Reciprocating Saw is Right for Me?

There are several different types and brands of reciprocating saws available on the market so finding the one that is right for you will probably take some research and testing. In this section I will go over some of the most popular models and explain what you need to consider before making your purchase.

Features to Consider

Amps: The amperage determines how powerful the tool is and in the case of a reciprocating saw, the more powerful it is, the better it will be for heavy duty work. Most models have an amp range from 6 up to 15. The higher the number, the more powerful the tool.

Blades: The type of blade a saw uses is probably the most important factor to consider. The main types of blades are stainless steel, hardened steel and bi-metal. Each type has its pros and cons so you will have to think about what you will be using the tool for and then choose the appropriate type of blade.

Sources & references used in this article: